Best Neutral Milk Hotel songs, ranked

All 22 Neutral Milk Hotel songs ranked from best to worst by community rating. 22 ratings.

View the chart

All songs 22

  1. In the Aeroplane Over the SeaIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19989.5
  2. King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 1In the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19989.3
  3. Where You’ll Find Me NowOn Avery Island · 19969.2
  4. NaomiOn Avery Island · 19969.2
  5. Three PeachesOn Avery Island · 19969.1
  6. Oh ComelyIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19989.1
  7. Gardenhead / Leave Me AloneOn Avery Island · 19969.0
  8. Communist DaughterIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19989.0
  9. GhostIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.9
  10. [untitled]In the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.9
  11. King of Carrot Flowers Pts. 2 & 3In the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.8
  12. Two-Headed BoyIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.8
  13. Two-Headed Boy Pt. 2In the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.8
  14. Avery Island / April 1stOn Avery Island · 19968.7
  15. Holland, 1945In the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.7
  16. A Baby for PreeOn Avery Island · 19968.6
  17. Marching ThemeOn Avery Island · 19968.6
  18. The FoolIn the Aeroplane Over the Sea · 19988.6
  19. Song Against SexOn Avery Island · 19968.5
  20. Everything Is…On Avery Island · 19968.5
  21. April 8thOn Avery Island · 19968.3
  22. Pree-Sisters Swallowing a Donkey’s EyeOn Avery Island · 19968.0